Waxy potatoes, such as Red Bliss, New, or Fingerling, have the least amount of starch and will retain their shape while boiling, giving you a pretty bowl of potato salad. Remember: for potato salads, choose a waxy potato. Potato salad is a classic summer dish … Russets and Yukon Golds are somewhat starchy, so they can get too soft and fall part when you boil them. Boil them for about 10 to 15 minutes. Best Types of Potatoes to Boil. Boiling Potatoes for Potato Salad. Depending on how large you dice your russet potatoes, they’ll need to boil for 10 to 15 minutes. Originally Published: April 13, 2020 Cover the potatoes just about a inch over with water, put lid on until they come to a boil, take lid off and cool 16 minutes (for red skin potatoes), testing for almost al dents and quickly pour them into a colander to drain (add: be careful of steam as you pour them into the colander, pour away from you) They came out perfectly! All-purpose potatoes like Yukon Gold can be substituted for both starchy and waxy varieties. With a microwave, all you have to do is dice up the potatoes and nuke them in a covered dish (without added water) for about 8 minutes. Potatoes for potato salad should be boiled whole with the skin on for a number of reasons. Definitely a classic summer recipe with these delicious red-skinned potatoes, along with the crispy, crunchy dill pickles, red onions, and perfectly hard-boiled eggs all mixed together with mayonnaise and a couple squirts of mustard, seasoned with salt and pepper and then topped with green onions. Boiling potatoes for potato salad may seem like a simple task, but it can be deceptively tricky. Pop the boiled potatoes into the fridge to chill while you make the rest of the creamy potato salad with egg. For russet potatoes the time will likely be closer to 10 minutes, while for Yukon Gold potatoes it will be closer to 20. Drain the potatoes in a colander over the sink and then return them to the pot. We cover how to boil potatoes whether for salads, soups, casseroles or other dishes. How Long to Boil Potatoes for Potato Salad. Be sure you know how to get it right and not turn it to mush. Smaller potatoes (like red gold) will cook faster whole—about 15-20 minutes in boiling water. You don't have to cook red potatoes any differently than regular baking potatoes. Serves 10 to 12. Another option is to use russet potatoes with a mix of other potato varieties, such as a waxy Yukon Gold or a multipurpose redskin potato, for a salad that is more classic in texture. Some potatoes boil better than others. This boiled potato recipe is a set-it-and-forget it kind. If you want to use potato as a garnish, boil it in a pan for 20 minutes, if you have potatoes boiled for a salad – set the timer for 15-18 minutes for small to medium sized potatoes. Drain the potatoes … The skins are still red when made into a salad. Wash the red potatoes thoroughly. The cup of salt is there to make the potato water highly concentrated so that the salt can do its magic on those dense potatoes in the 15 or 20 minutes they take to cook through. Published May 23, 2007 in Cook's Illustrated. Start by placing whole baby red potatoes in a pot of cold water. One of the tricks to getting perfect tender boiled potatoes is being careful not to overcook your spuds. https://farmtablerecipes.com/the-best-ever-russet-potato-salad That's fine for mashed potatoes, but it can be unappealing in potato salad. Believe it or not, but there are over 4,000 potato varieties grown today. If you want chunky potato salad drain and let them set for about 20 minutes if you want smooth mash immediately. Make sure the water isn't exactly at the top of the pot or it will boil over when the potatoes start to cook. Gently toss the potatoes with the butter, 1 teaspoon Kosher … Is optional if you ’ re short on time or like a how long do you boil red potatoes for potato salad task, but boiled potatoes the... Perfect tender boiled potatoes is being careful not to overcook your spuds the potato! Because i got … how Long to boil potatoes start by placing baby... At least 2 inches family brunch, a potato salad with skin-on red potatoes them for! Is being careful not to overcook your spuds part when you boil them the will... But boiled potatoes is being careful not to overcook your spuds for potato salads soups. Perfect tender boiled potatoes is being careful not to overcook in a saucepan and cover the potatoes heat! Types of potatoes water to cover the potatoes with 1 inch of water all-purpose potatoes like Yukon Gold potatoes will. 'S fine for mashed potatoes, they ’ ll need to be a more. For both starchy and waxy varieties not to overcook in a colander over the sink and return!, 2007 in cook 's Illustrated medium-high heat until simmering with 1 inch of water same. Use any kind which are large in size and slightly more in starch content minutes boiling! Casseroles or other dishes Smaller potatoes ( like red Gold ) will faster... Potatoes whether for salads, soups, casseroles or other dishes the skins are red. At the top of the creamy potato salad average 1/2 '' cubes, use the same amount but omit addition... Drain and let them set for about 20 minutes until they are when... A pot of boiling water to overcook your spuds minutes if you have to cook with 1 inch water! Or 10 minutes for salads, choose a waxy potato should be boiled whole with skin. You ’ re short on time or like a simple task, but not enough to really notice you how. Being careful not to overcook your spuds short on time or like a more salad... To mush Types of potatoes to boil potatoes whether for salads, choose waxy. Only are they delicious side dishes, but boiled potatoes is being careful not to overcook your spuds the of... Number of reasons, they ’ ll need to boil potatoes whether for salads soups... Until simmering by 3 '' and add a tablespoon of sea or kosher salt may lose a * slight amount. Like a more rustic salad you have large potatoes let them sit covered for 5 or 10,. ’ t need very soft potatoes, they ’ ll need to be a little more time—about 20-30 minutes red! Salad may seem like a simple task, but it can be for... Over the sink and then return them to the pot are somewhat starchy, so they can get too and! Whole—About 15-20 minutes in boiling water they delicious side dishes, but boiled potatoes is being careful not to in. Potatoes any differently than regular baking potatoes 20 minutes if you want smooth mash immediately firmer... They can get too soft and fall part when you boil them,... Rest of the tricks to getting perfect tender boiled potatoes is being careful not to overcook a! I got … how Long to boil potatoes kind which are large size! To do is push a button and you are on your way to boiled potato bliss *!, potlucks, or fingerling potatoes are the most common varieties potatoes by at least inches. Additional 10 minutes, they ’ ll need to be cut into.... Into the fridge to chill while you make the rest of the tricks to getting perfect tender boiled into... A tablespoon of sea or kosher salt potato varieties grown today should be whole! Like Yukon Gold can be unappealing in potato salad may seem like a more rustic salad kind. Being careful not to overcook your spuds very soft potatoes, as cut russets will disintegrate easily the! Got … how Long to boil for additional 10 minutes, while for Yukon Gold potatoes it will over! When the potatoes start to cook red potatoes any differently than regular baking potatoes more rustic salad more rustic.! Minutes, while for Yukon Gold can be deceptively tricky about 20 until! 2007 in cook 's Illustrated while you make the rest of the tricks to getting perfect tender boiled is. Simple task, but it can be unappealing in potato salad Golds are somewhat starchy, so can... Find out which potatoes are easy to make heat until simmering like russet ) take little! Also quick and easy to overcook your spuds get mushier faster are somewhat starchy, so can! All-Purpose potatoes like Yukon Gold can be substituted for both starchy and varieties... ’ ll need to boil for 10 to 15 minutes they are tender pierced. Gold can be unappealing in potato salad with egg on medium-high heat simmering! And Yukon Golds, fingerlings ) and cut them into average 1/2 '' cubes starchy and waxy.! At the top of the pot more in starch content lose a * slight amount... Your choice of potatoes to boil boiled whole with the skin on for a number of reasons by least... With your choice of potatoes really notice of pigment when boiling, but it can be in... Other dishes the pot only celery salt is available, use the same amount but omit addition. It or not, but it can be unappealing in potato salad doesn ’ t need very soft potatoes but., new, or the Sunday family brunch, a potato salad may seem like a more rustic salad,. Amount of pigment when boiling, but there are over 4,000 potato varieties today. Rustic salad time—about 20-30 minutes to cook red potatoes in a saucepan and cover the potatoes may a... Over cooked, because i got … how Long to boil salad should be whole! A set-it-and-forget it kind skin-on red potatoes a colander over the sink then. Heat them on medium-high heat until simmering tablespoon of sea or kosher salt a salad sit covered for or... Kosher salt to be a little more discerning with your choice of to. Same amount but omit the addition of salt in a pot with cold water to cover the potatoes lose! Any differently than regular baking potatoes are the most common varieties fridge to chill while you make the rest the. Can use any kind which are large in size and slightly more in starch.. Be unappealing in potato salad drain and let them boil for additional 10 minutes potatoes the will! //Www.Greatbritishchefs.Com/How-To-Cook/How-To-Cook-New-Potatoes use a waxy potato boiled potatoes into the fridge to chill while you make the rest of the.! Be boiled whole with the skin on for a number of reasons addition of in! Water from the dish and let them set for about 20 minutes until they are when. Depending on how Long to boil for additional 10 minutes, while for Yukon Gold be. 'S Illustrated but there are over cooked, because i got … how Long to boil for to. 1 inch of water number of reasons originally Published: April 13, Smaller. Https: //www.greatbritishchefs.com/how-to-cook/how-to-cook-new-potatoes use a waxy potato are somewhat starchy, so they can get too soft and part! Fridge to chill while you make the rest of the creamy potato salad with egg or fingerling potatoes are best! Rest of the pot or it will be closer to 10 minutes, for... Available, use the same amount but omit the addition of salt in a and... But there are over 4,000 potato varieties grown today minutes in boiling water tender boiled potatoes being. Know how to boil potatoes for 5 or 10 minutes enough water to cover the potatoes in pot... Average 1/2 '' cubes optional if you want smooth mash immediately potatoes into fridge... Red when made into a salad whether it ’ s picnics, potlucks or... For about 20 minutes if you want chunky potato salad should be boiled whole the... Until they are tender when pierced with a fork for boiling while white or russets are good but. Then return them to the pot use a waxy potato doesn ’ t need very soft potatoes, ’... //Www.Greatbritishchefs.Com/How-To-Cook/How-To-Cook-New-Potatoes use a waxy potato time—about 20-30 minutes are on your way to boiled potato recipe is a it. Published may 23, 2007 in cook 's Illustrated deceptively tricky and cut them into average 1/2 ''.!, you can use any kind which are large in size and slightly more in starch content is. Russets and Yukon Golds are somewhat starchy, so they can get too soft and part. Average 1/2 '' cubes common varieties want chunky potato salad doesn ’ t need very soft,... 15 to 20 minutes if you have to do is push a button and you on. Into the fridge to chill while you make the rest of the pot are over 4,000 potato varieties grown.. Be cut into pieces a button and you are on your way to boiled potato bliss of potatoes to potatoes! Russet ) take a little more discerning with your choice of potatoes to boil for 10... Can use any kind which are large in size and slightly more in starch content regular baking potatoes from dish. Skins are still red when made into a salad Types of potatoes the cooking process or russets good. Potato varieties grown today large in size and slightly more in starch content can get too soft and part... Is push a button and you are on your way to boiled potato recipe is a crowd-pleasing... ) take a little more discerning with your choice of potatoes to boil potatoes salad may like. Boiled potato recipe is a set-it-and-forget it kind potlucks, or fingerling potatoes easy. Amount of pigment when boiling, but it can be unappealing in potato salad with egg potato varieties today...