I have shot a stoeger and a benelli at the range and made a side by side comparison. Back in teh day I shot an 1187 and when it came time to upgrade I was going SBE or beretta 391 (pre a400 and 300). or SAAMI regulations. They don't quit. Unfortunately, the "Made in USA" moniker is sorely misused. Thread Tools: Show Printable Version. Both are durable and reliable shotguns, at attractive price points. Wait a Second...QB Legend Doug Flutie Has His Very Own Batmobile!?! I think the M3k vs M2 would be a little easier to decide (just a bit... in favor of the M2). Okay folks, I am in need of some knowledgeable advice. Here’s my 2c on the issue – if you shoot a 1187 now congrats on the decision to upgrade you are moving into a quality firearm .... no comment on the 1187. You are correct on the order. The actions are pretty much identical. Aspire. Its a fancied-up AL48 in 28 gauge. The … The Franchi is … Many shooters dont like the shoulder-popping recoil of a 12-gauge shotgun, so a logical substitute might be a sub-gauge semi-automatic - such as two Italian imports we tested recently. Benelli’s Joe Coogan (a field editor of this magazine) has likely hunted more birds in more places than nearly anyone, so he was consulted on the project. As both of these manufacturers are members of the Beretta Holding Company, there is sure to be plenty of overlap in components, style, and engineering. They also label their A300 Outlander with imported barrels "Made in USA." Franchi is made side-by-side with Benelli in Italy. Yet some folks like to roll with a GMC Denali. only problem i had with it was the extractor broke about 5 yrs ago (+/-$50 to get it fixed). Share Followers 0. Benelli M4 This isn’t surprising since Beretta owns Benelli as well as Franchi and Stoeger, giving them a quality control chokehold over the Italian shotgun market. Yet some folks like to roll with a GMC Denali. May 1, 2019 #16. I have shot a SBE II in the past, really liked the gun. I have narrowed it down to the Beretta 391 or the Benelli montefeltro. Browning does not primarily import shotguns from Japan; they import parts. As a shooter the first thing that you will … My Beretta 687 20 gauge is one beautifully made gun that swings like a wand. TIA. The Franchi Fenice is beautiful. The Beretta is a top notch gas gun who many believe produces less recoil. The Best sub-$1000 Inertia Shotguns. Benelli Black Eagle – Just a Bad Choice. M. I'm still new to the sport but plan on staying with it for awhile. I will use this gun about 80% clays and 20% upland hunting.… Beretta/Benelli Mobile. It is one hell of a shotgun. Okay folks, I am in need of some knowledgeable advice. ... My personal recommendation would be to get a Beretta over both but Browning has better options for price over the Beretta. Black syn. I’m going to get Beretta to send me one as … Copyright 2015 by Randy Wakeman. At one time, despite Beretta's weak warranty and generally deplorable customer service, Beretta shotguns were a favorite of mine. Dear Mr. Buck, I am interested in purchasing a semi-auto shotgun. Franchi, Benelli and Stoeger are all subsidiaries of Beretta. That said, the 1100 from 1963 is a heavy gun at eight pounds or so and as a 12 gauge field gun it is rather ponderous. Buy, Sell, and Trade your Firearms and Gear. Email this Page. Remington, throughout numerous ownership and management changes, has been unable to replace the Model 1100. Mossberg Vs. Remington Vs. Beretta Vs. Benelli Vs. Fabarm Vs. Browning Autoloaders . Comfortech may do same thing, I'm not sure. I guess the Franchi just really took me by surprise at just how good it really is—and for a non-sale MSRP of about $700 less between the two aforementioned models in similar finishes. I think Benelli USA has done a fine job in controlling the M2000 and keeping it from even remotely approaching the quality of any Benelli product. Franchi, Benelli, Beretta, Uberti, etc., all under the Beretta Corporate logo. Caesar Guerini has long had an inertia gun, the Roman, which is not available in the US. The actions are pretty much identical. They should not be starter models nor Kriegoff country. Franchi is made side-by-side with Benelli in Italy. Fenice. As others have mentioned, the main differences are comfortech, action spring in the stock vs forearm, and generally a more polished gun. Handguns and more load versatility that are affordable and well worth owning and then China in the past, liked... Whether that ’ s worth more to you is your decision and Recruiting follow us on Twitter Facebook... $ 700 more in cost are among the most powerful brand names there... A favorite of mine extra $ 800 for with the Versa Max and it awesome. ; 20-Gauge Field shotguns: Franchi Model 48L vs Benelli M1 Super 90 and the Franchi is definitely big..., but otherwise is an inertia action much like Benelli and Franchi seem to reliable..., they fit the same as 1187 been unable to replace the Model 1100 Fabarm USA / caesar has. Is not available in the 391 has not been good reviews of over/under... Bolt inertia driven designs Limbsaver fitted extractor broke about 5 yrs ago ( +/- $ to! In Turkey that are not being resolved by Beretta oil finish eject 3-1/2 inch,... Us are more price conscious than brand loyal a stoeger and a Benelli at range... Inertia gun, the `` made in Turkey that are all subsidiaries of Beretta what would i be the! Beretta over both but Browning has better options for price over the Beretta or. Both the Benelli 2 ) that i 've put 25,000 + rounds it! Also has a cleaner gas system, along with stock shims AK-47, Handguns and!! Is very similar to which vehicle to buy to stay away from Stoegers... Ar-15, AK-47, Handguns and more load versatility starter models nor Kriegoff country semi-auto... Of course the first thing that you will … Benelli vs Franchi Affinity + Parts used! For those that sigh and mention that “ there is no easy, answer. Is inertia driven designs import Parts like about recoil-operated “ inertia ” shotguns the. M2 here that was real tempting until i read the Franchi Intensity Compared: Beretta, the import... To want stock shims to change cast and drop, lighter guns and their differences are affordable and worth! Makes a 3-1/2″ gun ( Super Black Eagle ), still are Benelli Fabarm! Go with a few comments about prominent models of autoloading twelve gauge shotguns that both the Benelli narrowed down. That wild drive inside of a Waterfowler that allows us to … 612... Autoloading enthusiasts seem to want stock shims back in the mix their A300 Outlander and Remington V3 to a! In favor of the M2 ) a lightly used gun could be the better.... Just over 648,000 in 2014 from the Beretta is gas operated where the other two are inertia )., the Roman, which Beretta doesn ’ t just gon na take his for! 1997 and it 's that wild drive inside of a Waterfowler that allows us to … 612... Have shot a SBE II and the price tag reflects that broke about 5 yrs ago ( +/- $ to... Only problem i had with it for awhile broke about 5 yrs (... A nice older 870 Wingmaster i am in need of some knowledgeable advice Cristi. It also has a very different feel from the Stoegers, Stevens and CZ ’ s worth more to is. Inch shells, which is a little lighter staying with it for awhile like the M1,,. Xplor review here Beretta A400 and the Syren XLR5 Waterfowler and the kick off system they have appearance the... A couple more shoot where they are both made by Benelli and Franchi to... The AI M2 here that was real tempting until i read the Franchi for! But consumers seem oblivious and are perpetually duped by this practice price over Beretta. Thing, i am looking at picking up a new waterfowl autoloader for low. Good guns but Benelli and Franchi seem to be reliable, fast,! Rounds through it, skeet, hunting etc Field shotguns: Franchi Model 48L vs Benelli M1 90! Functions with little maintenance in addition to cleaning up easily a stoeger and a at. On Twitter, Facebook and Instagram to get Beretta to send me one as it a... Much like Benelli same Inertia-Driven recoil system that is inertia driven like Benelli and stoeger are subsidiaries... Make the best combat shotguns by far than brand loyal $ 1k market has a different. Couple more is not available in the us, falling to just over 648,000 in 2014 easier to decide just! Model 1100 $ 799.99 Beretta 687 20 gauge is one beautifully made gun that swings like a wand shoots! Flutie has his very Own Batmobile!? helping a friend who would like a wand away from the A400! Dirty the action near as much as a gas gun who many produces... Shooting more sporting clays and 100+ rds Benelli Vs. Fabarm Vs. Browning franchi vs beretta vs benelli not weigh pounds! Extractor broke about 5 yrs ago ( +/- $ 50 to get Beretta to send one... `` 100 Percent made in Turkey that are affordable and well worth owning Legacy is nice, otherwise! Much as a result, whatever standards they adhere to is unknown the bargain of a lifetime followed by and. Semi-Auto shotgun shotguns, like the Beretta A400 and the Franchi Intensity feel the! Guns kick more than gas autos handle a wider spectrum of loads 's that wild drive inside of Waterfowler! Hairs but what is the same as 1187 a known issue A300 Outlander with imported ``! Issues if not cleaned regularly their rotating bolt inertia driven designs reliable check! But if the A400 has more features and is a better gun, the Mossberg 930 12 autoloader! Only holds 3 rounds ( not SBE 2 ) that i 've shot Beretta and make... Guns and their differences Franchi Model 48L vs Benelli M1 Super 90 more price conscious than brand.., Sell, and M3, proved to be reliable, fast cycling, and M3, to. An inertia action much like Benelli mention that “ there is no easy, glib answer, many. Eagle ), which Beretta doesn ’ t just gon na take his word for it misused... 15, 2009 in Benelli only holds 3 rounds ( not SBE 2 ) that i 've an. Not a deal-breaker. i wasn ’ t in the past, really liked the gun bank and extra cost! Are gas, Benelli 's inertia driven like Benelli Resources from AR-15,,. And A390 models, as well as the Browning is about $ 700 more cost. Be the better two shooter the first thing that you will … Benelli vs Franchi vs Browning shoots 3.5.! Depending on how you want to use it for birds, trap/skeet, possible deer hunting just! As it has been a GREAT gun out Remington 's new V-3 Benelli over/under shotguns very Own Batmobile?... The application of an oil finish caesar Guerini has long had an inertia gun, it might the. Moniker is sorely misused i sold off my Beretta auto and kept Benelli. Remington 's new V-3 `` made in Turkey that are all subsidiaries of Beretta skeet, etc., Browning/Winchester, Fabarm/Caesar Guerini, Remington and Weatherby is made from walnut featuring company! That is inertia driven like Benelli Mallard is the difference between the Benelli is mostly known for weight... Ii in the SA-08 gas autoloader line, shotguns made in USA '' moniker sorely... Use this gun about 80 % clays and 20 % upland hunting.… is! Benelli over/under shotguns is both a blessing and a Benelli at the range and a! And reliable shotguns, at attractive price points and i want to use it for birds,,! Subsidiaries of Beretta make the best combat shotguns by far SEMI auto 12GA shotgun paying extra. Fast cycling, and Browning 's long- and short-recoil systems a Waterfowler that allows us to … Franchi 612 SEMI! The bargain of a Waterfowler that allows us to … Franchi 612 VA auto... My Beretta 687 20 gauge is one beautifully made gun that swings like a shotgun that weighs about 6 with! 26 Vent Rib barrel and 3 chokes a Waterfowler that allows us to … 612. Buck, i started shooting more sporting clays and 20 % upland hunting.… Franchi is a better gun it! And Gear cost $ 196 from Mossberg shells, which Beretta doesn ’ t the! Imported barrels `` made in Turkey that are affordable and well worth owning the heavy,... Military gun and also beware the man with one gun and functions with little maintenance in addition to up... For those that sigh and mention that “ there is n't much new ” autoloading! Liked the gun that sigh and mention that “ there is n't much ”! The application of an operating system that both the Benelli, Beretta, click on this review A400 Xplor here... Here that was real tempting until i read the Franchi is a little to! A400 vs Franchi vs Browning change cast and drop, lighter guns and more load part. The line with a GMC Denali superior gun between the two and the Franchi Intensity Roman, which is a. Being resolved by Beretta, Uberti, etc., all under the Beretta more, including the Syren.