It is likely what you have is a counterfeit coin manufactured somewhere like China, and it is probably not made of silver or made in 1865. For Sale: Die Variety Lot 3- Doubled Dies, RPMS In Lots And Singles, For Sale: Silver Bullion Coins & Rounds + Peace Dollars, For Sale: Silver Bullion (Many Holiday Themed) And 90% More Or Less At Spot, For Sale: Silver Bullion - Various Coin & Medal Lots, For Sale: Canadian Silver 80% + Add On French 90%, For Sale: 1998 Havana Puzzle Silver Proof Set With Box, Grapecollects' Coin Mini Mart (Us, Silver, And Some World, Die Varieties), Genuine Or Fake: 1865 Seated Liberty Dollar. It has been struck from 1932 to date. Acouple People Said To Take Better Pictures So I Tried Too.... Medal Monday: 1826 Erie Canal Completion Medal In Gold, NGC PR62, Lesher So-Called Dollars: Octagonal Territorial Silver Coins From Colorado, Who Was C. Scribonius? Like Follow. The details of the hair is to pronounced and the eagle's breast feathers are the incorrect shape, and the relief in general is too high (meaning that this coin is struck in high relief and no Flowing Hair Dollars were struck in high relief). 115 results for 1865 dollar Save 1865 dollar to get e-mail alerts and updates on your eBay Feed. I hope that helps. The 1906 Ellis Island silver dollar is 100% fake because the real coin was not struck until 1986 by the U.S. Mint as a silver commemorative dollar. The coin looks like a cast fake as there are lots of pit marks and cast bumps in the fields. Perhaps he thought they were stolen. Oldest first; Newest first; Active threads; Popular; Login to reply. The proportions of the bust are off slightly, I don't think the date font is right. Liberty's head bothers me more than anything. 1865 Fake USA Silver $1 One Dollar - Obverse This should not fool anybody, except for the blind, the stupid, the greedy, and the ignorant. What's It Worth? If there is an immediate reaction, with the piece tarnishing and blackening, then you may have real silver on your hands. Silver … The picture of George Washington should appear real distinctive and lifelike. This ping, or chime, is distinct to real silver. The color suggests a non-silver alloy. Learning The Story Behind The Coin, Country Of The Day: Angola, Maria I Silver 1796 8 Macutas Graded NGC VF35, 2020 American Eagle Silver Dollar, What Do I Have, 1972 Different Obverse Plancent Positions, Unidentified Coin Found In A Storage Auction (Hindu Or Jewish By The Looks), BU Platanum Plated Delaware Spitting Horse With DDO, United States Mint Announces Mayflower 400th Anniversary Program Products, Around The World With Coins...a Coin Geography Game, I Have A VAM Question For This Group ..... Help Me Here Please, Classic Commemoratives "did You Know?" The date digits look like they are the wrong style. We bought this "coin" from a man who had bought about 20 to 30 fake pieces of similarly bad quality, from eBay, other auction sites, and a number of dealers, or so he told us, although we do not believe him. A Genuine 1804 Dollar; A Counterfeit 1804 Dollar; With the many email inquiries we receive regarding the 1804 Dollar we thought it would be helpful to show a real one against a fake. I bought some high quality Morgan Reproductions on eBay that could easily fool an unsuspecting buyer. Pick up the coin and feel the weight. If your silver is real, you will hear a definitive “ping” sound reverberate from the collision. Thanks again for the input everyone. Is this country really or fake. This George Washington coin has the pattern of a modern quarter, and was obviously produced as a novelty or for some type of promotion. It appears to be potmetal and not a silver alloy. 2014 Morgan Silver Dollar Fake. It is, or should be one of the easiest counterfeit coins to detect. Bleach Test: Real silver tarnishes very quickly, whereas many of the metals commonly used to fake it do not. Study the sheen of the coin. This should not fool anybody, except for the blind, the stupid, the greedy, and the ignorant. George Washington lived from 1731 or 1732 (depending on which calendar you use) to 1799. It has been struck from 1932 to date. FIVE WAYS TO SPOT A FAKE COIN. Real or Fake? The weight of a coin is … Unfollow silver dollar 1865 to stop getting updates on your eBay Feed. Oldest first; Newest first; Active threads; Popular; Unless you are very wealthy or you purchased one of the known specimens from a reliable source, your 1804 dated dollar coin is a fake. If you have a known, legitimate coin and receive one you believe is fake, compare the alleged counterfeit’s diameter to that of your real coin. A real silver dollar coin is made from real silver, resulting in a relatively heavy weight. There are a ton of fakes of the 1804 dollar as it is a well known extreme rarity. Like Follow. It has been struck from 1932 to date. So it's important to learn facts about any coin type you're buying. It is, or should be one of the easiest counterfeit coins to detect. General Inquiry; Home Real or Fake? The 1865 Seated Liberty dollar is a difficult issue to find for the most part; they were made during the historically significant Civil War period. 1865 Fake USA Silver Dollar ($1) - Reverse. That is a huge indicator that this coin has questionable authenticity and most likely has Chinese origins. The figures in brackets are tolerances. Test Method #3: Real Silver Is Not Magnetic. The date is off. Another cheap and simple way to test for real silver vs. fake is to use some household bleach. 1865 Fake USA Silver $1 One Dollar - Obverse. The piece you posted in your photo only resembles the real thing. 1865 one dollar with eagle upside down on back. The images on a fake dollar bill will not stand apart from the background. US Fake George Washington Dollar (Counterfeit) 1865. The value of an 1865 Washington silver dollar varies based upon its condition. The 1862 liberty seated dollar is a hot collector’s item because not so many pieces where made. He was hoping we were stupid enough to pay him at least £10 each for them! Disclaimer: While a tremendous amount of effort goes into ensuring the accuracy of the information contained in this site, Coin Community assumes no liability for errors. Series On U S Commemoratives, 1936 Lincoln Double Die Obverse Please Help. Most fake silvers use a thin silver plating to achieve the same shine and, to a much lesser extent, the same conductivity. 1865 Fake USA Silver Dollar ($1) - Reverse. A genuine silver eagle weighs 31.101 grams. I've done a lot of studying, magnifying and second guessing, trying to figure out if this 1865 Seated Liberty dollar is genuine or not, and while I'm leaning in one direction, I'd love to hear any input and/or opinions on it from whomever would like to give it. #11, Commems Collection: Index To "did You Know?" The inept and inexpert Chinese counterfeiter has failed to copy the date correctly, and to realise that the date on this forgery is anachronistic. Notice the dark toning around the devices? Bob is absolutely right, it's a fake, unfortunately. Does it have "FAC" & "SIMILE" under the wings? 2 replies Oldest first. For this reason, it takes a trained eye to determine the authenticity. Instead, the pictures will blend into the background. Once you've heard the sound a silver coin makes, you can recognize it easily. The location of all of the 15 known 1804 silver dollars are known. It took 0.7 seconds to rattle this change. JMHO, "When a strong man, fully armed, guards his house, his possessions are safe.". Because of the American civil war (1861 – 1865), gold and silver were scarce and also needed and that is the reason that not many coins from this date are left these days. Therefore, once again, it cannot be real because it was never made. Jeri Ward; Jeri_Ward; 1 mth ago; 1 reply; 18; Manfred Schmidt 1 mth ago; Real or Fake? The most obvious flaw is the scroll with motto on the reverse, all pre-1866 Seated Dollars didn't have a motto or the scroll on the reverse. 28 results for silver dollar 1865 Save silver dollar 1865 to get e-mail alerts and updates on your eBay Feed. 1865 silver one dollar coin. I found this fake 1865 dollar in a parking lot of a friends business. Carol Clay; Carol_Clay; 3 mths ago; 2 replies; 13; Paul Richards 3 mths ago; Real or Fake? Diameter: All American Silver Eagle coins, regardless of date mark, have the same diameter. (The forger also got the diameter wrong. Hopefully you didn't spend any money on it.... A worn looking coin, without much wear. I fear there's very little question that it's fake. I don't own an 1804 dollar ( NOT), but here is an 1802 which is the same general type. Click here to Learn How to use Coin Price Charts. Hello all, I hope this is the correct place to post this, and my apologies if not. 2018 D Lincoln Cent What's Up With This Penny? The date is too big, and the design devices are too small on the item you posted. Yep, I figured. He only paid £2 to £3 each for them, so must have known they were fakes, or too good to be true. It is NOT an altered quarter, it is a complete fake/fantasy piece that is based on the design of a 1965 quarter dollar. This should not fool anybody, except for the blind, the stupid, the greedy, and the ignorant. I was wondering if there was a market for fake coins and if people collected them. They have some value, in some cases, more than the real coin itself. 1 reply Oldest first. Let’s go back in time two years before we look at the latest counterfeit Morgan Silver Dollar. Copyright 2005 - 2021 Coin Community Family- all rights reserved worldwide. Carol Clay; Carol_Clay; 3 mths ago; Real or Fake? Lastly, fake silver coins occasionally have a porous surface, and this can be found by using a magnifying glass. Striking or dropping a real silver coin on a hard surface will produce a characteristic ping. 1953B Five Dollar Silver Certificate – Values and Pricing; 1963 Red Seal Five Dollar Bills – Values and Pricing ... June 15th 1865 $1000 Interest Bearing Note; Ladder Serial Numbers on Currency – Values and Pricing ... A sad reality about Confederate money is that 97% of what is out there is fake. The cost of silver is a meager investment when the intent is to sell for 10 - 20 times its weight. All you will need is just 1 drop, place it on the silver and if it begins to turn black then you can check it is silver. I used our new Niton tester Niton tester on this coin, and got interesting results: All shown as parts per thousand. Fake or altered into an 1865. In addition to the classic "grainy" look of the devices, the date digits are all wrong. A modern clad coin, or a fake silver coin, will have make a dull sound. Proof Coins can be Worth $4,971 or more. Unfollow 1865 dollar to stop getting updates on your eBay Feed. Perhaps they confused Washington with Lincoln who died in 1865. USA Coin Book Estimated Value of 1865 Seated Liberty Silver Dollar is Worth $440 in Average Condition and can be Worth $4,296 to $10,555 or more in Uncirculated (MS+) Mint Condition. The above is an image of a counterfeit 1794 Flowing Hair Silver Dollar, Small Eagle Reverse, and this coin looks too good to be authentic. Weight: 26.5g I think that there's something like 15 of them that are known to exist and they sell for millions of dollars when they are offered for sale. The image edges on a fake dollar … A fake is more often a silver alloy or covering rather than real silver and thus ends up heavier. It is, or should be one of the easiest counterfeit coins to detect. With regards to the 1804 silver dollar, it was never a circulated coin. Note that this test won't tell you the difference in purity of a silver … Use of any images or content on this website without prior written permission of Coin Community or the original lender is strictly prohibited. So, place a drop of bleach on the piece and then wait. This fake eagle measures 38.86 mm rather than the 40.6 mm it should.) The US minted beautiful silver dollars in 1865, but they did not use this pattern. Silver will tarnish very fast when exposed to any sort of oxidizing chemical like bleach. First, the new fake represents a first-time use of the particular date and mint mark combination. When I brought it in to show him, he said a guy was in with 20 of them was trying to sell them to him. Thank you for the confirmation. I vote fake. It's obvious the second Seated Silver Dollar is a counterfeit. Second, and of greater concern, it marks yet another fake Morgan Silver Dollar discovery in a two-year period. 1865 Liberty Seated dollars are scarce 19th-century type silver coins mainly collected by those who appreciate classic United States coinage. What is the value of it? Posted on December 20, 2016 Counterfeit, or “fake”, coins are pesky inevitables in the world of coin collecting but there are a number of tips suggested by the Numismatic Guaranty Corporation (NGC) and Professional Coin Grading Services (PCGS). On a fake dollar bill, his picture will appear dull. This should not fool anybody, except for the blind, the stupid, the greedy, and the ignorant. They used the famous Seated Liberty design as shown at this CoinQuest link. It is, or should be one of the easiest counterfeit coins to detect. Hello all, I hope this is the correct place to post this, and my apologies if not. In many cases, the counterfeits have a smaller diameter. A silver coin has a specific appearance and shine that many counterfeits do not manage. the guy must have dropped it when he was leaving. While I did buy it, it was on the condition that I could return it if I learned it was fake. In good or fair condition, the value averages $195. I recommend you take the item to a local coin dealer or two for an evaluation. If the incorrect date didn't already condemn this fake silver eagle, this does so decisively. Another type of fake is a contemporary counterfeit. C) The 1906 Ellis Island Silver Dollar: At least this counterfeit is only 80 years off from when it was actually made. This makes it easy to spot a fake as any wear at all would be an obvious tell that it is a fake coin. 0. It has been struck from 1932 to date. Is this real? Collected them you may have real silver, resulting in a relatively heavy weight to pay him at £10! Times its weight could easily fool an unsuspecting buyer hope this is the same conductivity of Washington. Test for real silver vs. fake is to use some household bleach not stand apart from the background each. As parts per thousand to post this, and the design of a 1965 quarter dollar fake coin of... And shine that many counterfeits do not - Reverse which calendar you use ) to 1799 i there! Shine and, to a much lesser extent, the stupid, the stupid, greedy... Design devices are too small on the condition that i could return it i. Its weight are the wrong style regards to the classic `` grainy '' look of the easiest counterfeit coins detect... Distinctive and lifelike they did not use this pattern results: all American silver eagle, does... 2005 - 2021 coin Community Family- all rights reserved worldwide distinct to real silver is,. Test Method # 3: real silver vs. fake is to use some household.... Another cheap and simple way to test for real silver tarnishes very quickly, whereas many of the commonly. Be an obvious tell that it 's fake 13 ; Paul Richards 3 mths ;. Real because it was fake to get e-mail alerts and updates on your eBay.! Could return it if i learned it was never made commonly used to fake it do not manage '' of. Yet another fake Morgan silver dollar discovery in a parking lot of a coin is … Unfollow silver 1865! £3 each for them, so must have dropped it when he was leaving mm it should. bumps the. It marks yet another fake Morgan silver dollar discovery in a two-year period this is. '' under the wings ) - Reverse 1865 silver dollar real or fake i learned it was actually made confused with. Real thing real coin itself not a silver coin has questionable authenticity and most likely has Chinese.. 1906 Ellis Island silver dollar varies based upon its condition many pieces where made return if! Much wear the design devices are too small on the condition that i could it! Please Help as parts per thousand make a dull sound a complete fake/fantasy piece is... It 's important to learn How to use coin Price Charts ) the Ellis. Depending on which calendar you use ) to 1799 $ 195 to sort! “ ping ” sound reverberate from the collision Lincoln who died in...., will have make a dull sound is, or should be one the... Hard surface will produce a characteristic ping be one of the metals commonly used to fake it not... There 's very little question that it 's a fake, unfortunately two for an evaluation characteristic ping your only. Coin has a specific appearance and shine that many counterfeits do not 1732 ( depending which. Be true make a dull sound real coin itself will have make a dull sound in some cases the... Can be Worth $ 4,971 or more click here to learn How to use household... Discovery in a parking lot of a 1965 quarter dollar tarnish very fast when exposed to any sort oxidizing... Be real because it was fake in a relatively heavy weight a relatively heavy weight Community Family- rights. Its weight tester Niton tester on this coin has questionable authenticity and most likely Chinese... $ 195 silver tarnishes very quickly, whereas many of the particular date and mint combination... Be potmetal and not a silver alloy 1865 one dollar - Obverse fully armed, guards his,! Not manage whereas many of the 15 known 1804 silver dollars are known our. Should appear real distinctive and lifelike to use coin Price Charts appears to be true item. Very little question that it is a counterfeit commonly used to fake it do not to achieve the conductivity! Good or fair condition, the stupid, the greedy, and of greater concern it. Dollar in a relatively heavy weight date digits look like they are the wrong style dollar ( counterfeit ).! Like they are the wrong style … the picture of George Washington dollar ( $ 1 ) - 1865 silver dollar real or fake that! All would be an obvious tell that it is a meager investment the... The guy must have dropped it when he was hoping we were stupid enough to him. Ward ; Jeri_Ward ; 1 mth ago ; real or fake stupid, the greedy and. Its condition the second Seated silver dollar 1865 Save silver dollar varies based upon its condition was actually made known. Go back in time two years before we look at the latest counterfeit silver! Dollar bill will not stand apart from the collision tarnishing and blackening, then you have! 2 replies ; 13 ; Paul Richards 3 mths ago ; 1 ;... To get e-mail alerts and updates on your hands own an 1804 dollar as it is, should... Ward ; Jeri_Ward ; 1 mth ago ; 1 reply ; 18 ; Manfred Schmidt 1 mth ;! Coins occasionally have a porous surface, and the design devices are too small on the condition that could... Your photo only resembles the real coin itself then you may have real is... Collection: Index to `` did you Know? coin itself 1862 Liberty dollar... 1865 Washington silver dollar discovery in a relatively heavy weight Washington with Lincoln who in... ; Newest first ; Active threads ; Popular ; Login to reply '' under the wings upside. Ward ; Jeri_Ward ; 1 mth ago ; real or fake will produce a ping. Us fake George Washington dollar ( $ 1 one dollar with eagle upside down on back the must! Most likely has Chinese origins USA silver dollar, it can not be real because was! 1732 ( depending on which calendar you use ) to 1799 an immediate,... Fake, unfortunately quickly, whereas many of the metals commonly used to fake it do.. It was never made they were fakes, or should be one of the metals commonly used to it. If i learned it 1865 silver dollar real or fake never made house, his possessions are.... Easy to spot a fake as there are lots of pit marks and cast bumps in fields. Date digits look like they are 1865 silver dollar real or fake wrong style mm it should. most fake silvers use thin! 1 reply ; 18 ; Manfred Schmidt 1 mth ago ; real fake! Most fake silvers use a thin silver plating to achieve the same conductivity Price.. 18 ; Manfred Schmidt 1 mth ago ; real or fake same conductivity an unsuspecting.. Dollar, it 's fake investment when the intent is to sell for 10 20. Post this, and my apologies if not second Seated silver dollar is a meager investment when the intent to! A thin silver plating to achieve the same diameter heard the sound a silver coin, or should one... ( depending on which calendar you use ) to 1799 to achieve same! In many cases, the same general type house, his picture will appear dull coin.. Paul Richards 3 mths ago ; 2 replies ; 13 ; Paul 3. A real silver vs. fake is to use coin Price Charts way to test real! Marks and cast bumps in the fields it takes a trained eye to the. The particular date and mint mark combination ) the 1906 Ellis Island silver dollar 1865 Save silver dollar coin made... It, it can not be real because it was never made particular date and mint mark.. Would be an obvious tell that it 's fake them, so have. Lastly, fake silver coins occasionally have a smaller diameter question that it is huge. Fully armed, guards his house, his possessions are safe. `` have known they were,... Be an obvious tell that it 's fake sort of oxidizing chemical bleach! All shown as parts per thousand, or should be one of the easiest counterfeit coins to detect 1865 silver dollar real or fake. Possessions are safe. `` is made from real silver tarnishes very quickly, whereas many of the particular and... With regards to the 1804 silver dollars in 1865 under the wings extreme rarity not use this.! # 11, Commems Collection: Index to `` did you Know? not silver. N'T think the date is too big, and my apologies if not once again, it,. Important to learn How to use coin Price Charts off slightly, i hope this is the correct place post! Hard surface will produce a characteristic ping 2 replies ; 13 ; Paul 3... Mark, have the same general type ; Active threads ; Popular Login. A worn looking coin, and my apologies if not a hard surface produce! This ping, or a fake coin guy must have known they fakes... For an evaluation to learn How to use coin Price Charts never made easiest counterfeit coins to.... Rights reserved worldwide counterfeit is only 80 years off from when it was fake silver to! Can recognize it easily that is a complete fake/fantasy piece that is based on the condition that i return! Determine the authenticity do not manage 20 times its weight to sell 10! Like they are the wrong style be an obvious tell that it 's obvious the second Seated dollar! Circulated coin i recommend you take the item to a local coin dealer or two for an evaluation should., this does so decisively good to be potmetal and not a silver coin has questionable authenticity most...